Follow Us on Facebook and Instagram

Shop local🩷 Pints will be buy one, get one 50% off all day today for Small Business Saturday! Open until 8 today, see you soon❄️
Shop local🩷 Pints will be buy one, get one 50% off all day today for Small Business Saturday! Open until 8 today, see you soon❄️
Feeling #thankful🩷 Thank you to everyone who placed orders for this Thanksgiving! Forget to place your order? Don’t worry! We have a couple of extra pies available for purchase today. We hope everyone has a happy and safe holiday! Open until
Feeling #thankful🩷 Thank you to everyone who placed orders for this Thanksgiving! Forget to place your order? Don’t worry! We have a couple of extra pies available for purchase today. We hope everyone has a happy and safe holiday! Open until 8, see you soon🥧
Last call for Thanksgiving orders! We’ll be accepting orders through the end of the day tomorrow. To place your order, message us here, give us a call at (765) 221-9115, or visit us in store🧡
Last call for Thanksgiving orders! We’ll be accepting orders through the end of the day tomorrow. To place your order, message us here, give us a call at (765) 221-9115, or visit us in store🧡
Peppermint Stick is here❤️🤍 Come grab a scoop of this holiday favorite while supplies last! Open til 8, see you soon🍦
Peppermint Stick is here❤️🤍 Come grab a scoop of this holiday favorite while supplies last! Open til 8, see you soon🍦
Hey y’all☃️ Just letting you know we’ll be closed due to snow today. Bundle up at home today, and get your favorite ice cream this weekend! See you tomorrow🤍
Hey y’all☃️ Just letting you know we’ll be closed due to snow today. Bundle up at home today, and get your favorite ice cream this weekend! See you tomorrow🤍
Our hours will look a little different tomorrow, Saturday, November 16th, as we have a private event! We will be open 4-8. Sorry for any inconvenience🩷
Our hours will look a little different tomorrow, Saturday, November 16th, as we have a private event! We will be open 4-8. Sorry for any inconvenience🩷
On the first day of Christmas, my true love gave to me… Yummerful’s Ice Cream Advent Calendar🎄 We’re rolling out our advent calendars for the month of December! This year, we have our 12 Days of Ice Cream available or a 24 day a
On the first day of Christmas, my true love gave to me… Yummerful’s Ice Cream Advent Calendar🎄 We’re rolling out our advent calendars for the month of December! This year, we have our 12 Days of Ice Cream available or a 24 day advent calendar. Both are available in small or shareable sizes🎅🏼 These are perfect for the ice cream lover in your life! These will include some of our more popular flavors, seasonal flavors and even non-dairy. Call us, message us, or stop by in store for more info on how to order your adventure calendar today! Open til 8, see you soon🍦
We are officially taking holiday orders! Don’t feel like cooking for your family Thanksgiving? No worries, we’ve got you covered! To place your order, you can stop by in store, call during store hours, or message us here! To get your ord
We are officially taking holiday orders! Don’t feel like cooking for your family Thanksgiving? No worries, we’ve got you covered! To place your order, you can stop by in store, call during store hours, or message us here! To get your order for Thanksgiving, please order by Sunday, November 24th🦃
Today is the day! Grinch will be here at 3:30 today! Come by to get a picture and a cup of hot cocoa☕️ See you soon💚
Today is the day! Grinch will be here at 3:30 today! Come by to get a picture and a cup of hot cocoa☕️ See you soon💚
Oatmeal cream pies just made their highly anticipated return! Come snag yours while supplies last. Open til 8, see you soon🍪
Oatmeal cream pies just made their highly anticipated return! Come snag yours while supplies last. Open til 8, see you soon🍪
A little early for snow (we know,) but we couldn’t wait to make these glitter dusted snowflake marshmallows❄️ Open til 8, see you soon!
A little early for snow (we know,) but we couldn’t wait to make these glitter dusted snowflake marshmallows❄️ Open til 8, see you soon!
Come see us and get a cup of hot chocolate or some candy🍬☕️
Come see us and get a cup of hot chocolate or some candy🍬☕️
Shop local🩷 Pints will be buy one, get one 50% off all day today for Small Business Saturday! Open until 8 today, see you soon❄️ Feeling #thankful🩷 Thank you to everyone who placed orders for this Thanksgiving! Forget to place your order? Don’t worry! We have a couple of extra pies available for purchase today. We hope everyone has a happy and safe holiday! Open until Last call for Thanksgiving orders! We’ll be accepting orders through the end of the day tomorrow. To place your order, message us here, give us a call at (765) 221-9115, or visit us in store🧡 Peppermint Stick is here❤️🤍 Come grab a scoop of this holiday favorite while supplies last! Open til 8, see you soon🍦 Hey y’all☃️ Just letting you know we’ll be closed due to snow today. Bundle up at home today, and get your favorite ice cream this weekend! See you tomorrow🤍 Our hours will look a little different tomorrow, Saturday, November 16th, as we have a private event! We will be open 4-8. Sorry for any inconvenience🩷 On the first day of Christmas, my true love gave to me… Yummerful’s Ice Cream Advent Calendar🎄 We’re rolling out our advent calendars for the month of December! This year, we have our 12 Days of Ice Cream available or a 24 day a We are officially taking holiday orders! Don’t feel like cooking for your family Thanksgiving? No worries, we’ve got you covered! To place your order, you can stop by in store, call during store hours, or message us here! To get your ord Today is the day! Grinch will be here at 3:30 today! Come by to get a picture and a cup of hot cocoa☕️ See you soon💚 Oatmeal cream pies just made their highly anticipated return! Come snag yours while supplies last. Open til 8, see you soon🍪 A little early for snow (we know,) but we couldn’t wait to make these glitter dusted snowflake marshmallows❄️ Open til 8, see you soon! Come see us and get a cup of hot chocolate or some candy🍬☕️

Best in Madison County 2024

*

Best in Madison County 2024 *

Two Girls, a Dream, and some Ice Cream

Taking over in May 2022, this mom and daughter duo found a passion baking and serving ice cream to the small community of Pendleton.

image2.jpeg
image0.jpeg

What People Are Saying about Yummerful

“Absolutely delicious ice cream and THE BEST COOKIE EVER! The Cinnamon Roll cookies here are amazing! Great staff, great food, fun location in Historic downtown.”

— Ryan E., Google Reviews

“Super love the delicious frozen treats here! The staff are so awesome and enhance the atmosphere amazing well! The building itself bares such a historic light that would give any history buff goosebumps! We highly recommend this place! It's a beautiful hidden gem of Indiana! Already planning on going back very soon!”

— Charles B., Google Reviews

“Great staff, clean facility and amazing ice cream, with a really good selection, plus gluten free options!”

— Paul F., Google Reviews

“We are ice cream snobs and I can say they have the best ice cream ever hands down. Great flavors, excellent customer service, cute place, everything you could imagine. Did I mention the ice cream melts in your mouth it is so creamy? That's why it has taken us 10 times of going before I posted a review because its gone too quick before I get to take a picture. A must stop when in Pendleton. Oh and crazy good shakes! Try them all.”

— Tiffany L., Google Reviews

“Great place in a cute little part of town. The service was very friendly and they had a large variety of unique and cleverly named flavors that were delicious.”

— Melanie H., Google Reviews